Automation ROI: How to Calculate Your Savings

Automation promises to save time and money, but how do you know if it's worth the investment? By calculating the return on investment (ROI), you can justify the cost and prioritise the processes that deliver the greatest impact. Here's a simple framework to help you do the math.

Industry Benchmark: Well-implemented automation projects typically deliver ROI of 200-600% in the first year, with payback periods of 3-6 months.

💰 Step 1: Calculate the Cost of Manual Work

List all the tasks you currently perform manually. Estimate how many hours your team spends on each task per week and multiply by their hourly rate. Don't forget to include the hidden costs:

• Direct labour hours
• Error correction and rework
• Delays and missed deadlines
• Opportunity cost (what else could your team be doing?)

Real Example: Three employees at a distribution company spend 10 hours each week on data entry at $25/hour. Direct cost: $750/week or $39,000/year. But errors require an additional 3 hours/week of corrections ($3,900/year), bringing the true cost to $42,900/year.

Common Manual Process Costs

• Invoice processing: $15-$40 per invoice manually vs $3-$5 automated
• Data entry: $20-$35 per hour with 1-4% error rate
• Customer onboarding: 2-8 hours per client manually vs 15-30 minutes automated
• Report generation: 4-12 hours/week manually vs minutes automated

🔧 Step 2: Determine the Cost of Automation

Automation costs typically include:

One-time costs:

• Setup and configuration: $500-$5,000
• Custom development (if needed): $2,000-$20,000
• Training: $500-$2,000
• Data migration: $1,000-$5,000

Ongoing costs:

• Software subscriptions: $50-$500/month
• Maintenance: $50-$200/month
• Support: Often included in subscription

Example breakdown: A no-code automation tool costs $200/month ($2,400/year) with $1,500 setup. A custom integration might cost $5,000 to build but only $10/month to run ($120/year), totaling $5,120 in year one.

⏱️ Step 3: Estimate Time Saved

Be realistic but don't undersell the impact. Track time for less than 1 week to get accurate baselines.

Real Example: A marketing agency tracked their reporting process:

• Manual: 8 hours/week gathering data, creating reports
• Automated: 30 minutes/week reviewing auto-generated reports
• Time saved: 7.5 hours/week = 390 hours/year

At $50/hour billing rate: $19,500 in recoverable capacity that can be allocated to billable client work.

📊 Step 4: Compute ROI

Use this formula:

ROI = (Annual Savings - Annual Automation Cost) / Annual Automation Cost × 100%

Let's work through a complete example:

Scenario: E-commerce order processing automation

• Manual cost: 30 hours/week × $25/hour × 52 weeks = $39,000/year

• Error cost: 50 errors/month × $15 to fix = $9,000/year

• Total manual cost: $48,000/year

• Automation cost: $2,000 setup + $200/month = $4,400 first year

• Remaining manual cost: 3 hours/week × $25/hour × 52 = $3,900/year

• Total automated cost: $8,300/year

Annual savings: $48,000 - $8,300 = $39,700

ROI: ($39,700 - $4,400) / $4,400 × 100% = 802%

Payback period: $4,400 / ($39,700/12 months) = 1.3 months

After just 6 weeks, the automation has paid for itself.

✨ Step 5: Account for Intangible Benefits

Numbers don't capture everything. Factor in:

• Faster response times: Customers get instant confirmations instead of waiting hours
• Improved accuracy: Error rates drop from 2-4% to <0.1%
• Employee satisfaction: Teams spend time on meaningful work instead of repetitive tasks
• Scalability: Handle 3-5x volume with the same team
• Competitive advantage: Faster delivery and better service than competitors
• Stress reduction: No more weekend catch-up work or missed deadlines

Real Impact: A professional services firm automated their proposal generation. Beyond the 10 hours/week saved, they could now respond to RFPs in hours instead of days, increasing their win rate from 20% to 35%—a revenue impact far exceeding the direct cost savings.

---

🎯 Quick ROI Decision Matrix

Manual Cost/Year	Automation Cost	Minimum ROI to Proceed
< $10,000	< $1,000	200%+
$10,000-$50,000	$1,000-$5,000	150%+
$50,000-$100,000	$5,000-$15,000	100%+
> $100,000	$15,000+	50%+

Rule of thumb: If automation can pay for itself in under 12 months with measurable benefits, it's usually worth doing.

Start Your ROI Journey

Ready to calculate your specific savings?

1. Pick one process to analyze first (choose something high-volume and repetitive)
2. Track time for 2 weeks to get accurate baseline data
3. Research automation options and get realistic cost estimates
4. Calculate your ROI using the framework above
5. Present the business case with hard numbers

Get Expert Help

Not sure where to start or what to measure? Book your free workflow audit and we'll:

• Identify your highest-ROI automation opportunities
• Calculate your potential savings with real data
• Provide a detailed implementation roadmap
• Show you exact costs and timelines

The best automation projects pay for themselves in weeks, not years. Find out what's possible for your business—book your free audit today and unlock the hidden value in your processes.